levi bryant on badiou

Levi Paul Bryant: I’m not talking about Paul, but rather Badiou’s reading of Paul (I know that’s really scholastic, so don’t hate me too much for drawing the distinction!). I hope to write something about this when I get the time, but I think Badiou is doing something deeply necessary. My thesis is that we can describe the difference between the project of 20th century emancipatory project and 21st century emancipatory politics as the difference between class logic and set logic. When referencing class logic the names that should come to mind isn’t Marx but the Russel and Whitehead of the Principia. A class is a collection of entities defined by a shared intension or set of essential attributes. 20th century emancipatory political theory showed the fraught and untenable nature of these classes with respect to identity by demonstrating how they deconstruct themselves or are internally unstable or how they are historical or how they are social constructions, etc., thereby showing how they can’t function as legitimate grounds of privilege. Under Badiou’s reading, this would be part of what Paul was critiquing with respect to the privilege of various groups.

The problem is that while this deconstruction of social logics based on logical classes has been deeply necessary it didn’t take us very far in presenting an alternative picture of what social assemblages should be. Enter set logics. Set logics aren’t defined by a shared intenSion or set of essential properties defining membership under a shared identity, but rather sets are defined purely through extenSion. The members of the set need not share a common quality or essence– they can all differ completely from one another –to be members of that set because it’s simply the mere fact of existing (extension) that defines membership. In this regard, societies based on class logics are monarchic in that the essence defining identity functions as a monarch defining inclusion and exclusion, while societies based on a set logic are anarchic as there need be no common identity to be a member of the collective.

Badiou is angling for the latter. It’s difficult to see how this could possibly be a form of intolerance as there’s no essence (nationality, race, gender, economic status, knowledge expertise, etc) defining criteria for membership. Anyone and everyone can belong. So what we get here is the beginning of a picture of a post-postmodern social assemblage where it’s taken for granted that identity has been dissolved… Or something like that… A society based on mere existence rather than identifying predicates.

Levi Paul Bryant Daniel, I’m not sure that’s accurate. For Badiou it’s not that the Jew and Greek are ***overcome*** but that the Mosaic law as a condition for class membership and kinship descent as a condition for group membership become “indifferent”. So if you *want* go ahead and get circumcised and follow the dietary law, but this is no longer a *condition* for community membership. All the customs can be retained if one so desires, but these are no longer a foundation for the social assemblage. So in principle, under Badiou’s reading, such a community could be composed of Jew, Greek, *atheist*, Hindu, *satanist* (?!?!?!), pagan, etc. Those predicates no longer define the assemblage and membership shifts from being based on custom/law and origins (kinship) to being based on the work of love. Under my reading, the work of love means attending to the singular in each instance and acting according to what that singularity requires as response. For example, the law as a “bad universal” dictates that everyone that steals be imprisoned, while a society of love might look at the specific circumstances such as hunger, joblessness, childhood pathology that generated the symptom of cleptomania, as what needs to be addressed and in different ways in each circumstance. Again, it’s hard to see how this is intolerant, but maybe I’m giving Badiou too much credit… That’s what I take from it anyway.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *